20-10-2023

Algorithms to impact: advanced industrial automation solutions

In this blog we examine how different types of algorithm can improve automation solutions for industrial wastewater processing.

twinn aqua suite algorithms industrial wastewater
[object Object] [object Object]

BernardMcWeeney

With more than 20 years experience in the water and wastewater industry in commercial and technical roles, Bernard McWeeney is the Global Sales Director for Aqua Suite, Royal HaskoningDHV’s software solutions that look after and optimise the complete man-made water cycle.

Smart algorithms are the heart of any type of automation solution. Even before the invention of the transistor, knowledge about the process was converted into if-then logic that was being hardwired using relays to operate pumps, engines and valves. Fast forward a hundred years, and process control has come on leaps and bounds, especially with the rise of Industry 4.0 using Internet of Things (IOT), Big Data and artificial intelligence (AI). However, the fundamentals are still the same. Although ultimately a means to an end – by mitigating operational risks for industrial clients – find out more about the use of algorithms within Twinn Aqua Suite for Industrial wastewater processing.

It starts (and ends) with data

The fundamental for any type of process control is online measurement. In recent years, not only has more and more data become available, like flow, pH, and pressure, but there are also newer measurements finding their way to end users, like Total Organic Carbon (TOC). This opens new opportunities, especially in situations where the composition may be harder to predict or softsensor may not be possible. 

Sometimes, where the right data might not be directly available, then soft sensors may be used to indirectly derive certain parameters. The soft sensor for Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) used in the Anaerobic Controller is a good example. Of course, the availability, accuracy and frequency should be sufficient. Therefore, it is important to properly maintain and calibrate sensors. In case problems still occur, additional safeguarding in the software in the event that data goes missing or is unrealistic, is necessary. Anomaly or drift detection could further improves data quality, signaling operators to do maintenance in time. Next to the online data, less frequent lab or fixed, user values can be used as input into the different algorithms. 
Visualisation of typical process automation feedback loop
Typical process automation feedback loop

Where the magic happens

At Aqua Suite, we are firm believers in fit-for-purpose algorithms. This means first going for the simplest, least computing or data intensive solutions, with the biggest impact, before moving towards black-box type of technologies. This simplifies the software and the requirements for lengthy training of AI. on big data sets. It also makes it much easier to explain to the end user what the decision process is, instilling trust from the people that need to use the software. Of course, for more complicated, dynamic, fuzzy and multi-variable applications, like anomaly detection, there is no other way, than to use neural networks. The following types of algorithms may be used within Aqua Suite applications:

Basic logic:

operators like if-then or more basic feedback loops, like PI, PD or PID. These algorithms heavily depend on deep water domain knowledge and can traditionally also be found in SCADA/PLC programming. These algorithms can be great, but are always reactive, meaning that the systems are always playing catch-up. An example of this is to turn off a pump when a certain level in a buffer is reached. 

Machine learning:

these are algorithms that learn linear, or other types like exponential relationships between pre-set variables like load and aeration needed. These still depend on fundamental knowledge, but since the precise relationships can be different per reactor and depend on a lot of variables, the algorithm autonomously learns the exact relationship. An example of this is the relationship between the amount of polymer needed and the incoming dry-solids for sludge dewatering. Because of age, maintenance or other factors, decanter treating the same sludge might need slightly different amount of chemicals to reach the same result. 

Pattern recognition:

when taking a closer look at different types of data, you discover that many processes in the man-made water cycle follow patterns. An example is the diurnal consumption of drinking water and the subsequent flow to wastewater treatment plants. By using only a few weeks of historical data, an accurate prediction can be made up to 72h ahead, which in turn, can be used for feed-forward control, by anticipating what is to come instead of playing catch-up.  

Neural networks:

these types of advanced algorithms are becoming increasingly famous because of applications like ChatGPT. Neural networks can autonomously learn the relationships between many input parameters and prediction outcomes. This is especially useful with complex systems where typical domain knowledge would require a lot of modeling. Despite providing very useful insights, for example, by providing anomaly detection on pumps or drift detection for sensors, these models require large amounts of computing power and data. As this system is hard to explain and users require retraining when the system changes, this technology tends to be avoided for control type of applications, because of its lack of robustness for control type of applications.  

Visualisation of types of algorithms

The right balance for industry

For Aqua Suite, the sweet spot is making best use of 140+ years of domain knowledge and combining this with machine learning. Since industrial water processes are often more random, compared to their municipal counterparts, because of different production lines, products, planning and spills, future predictions are more uncommon. This means anticipating feed-forwards often depend more on online quality measurements or soft-sensoring, and less on heavy use of historical data. Luckily, the algorithms used are less computation intensive and can be done on premise, which poses less of a safety threat.
Whitepaper

The virtual operator that never retires

In this whitepaper, discover how to make the virtual operator part of your operations teams.
Download now
How to integrate the virtual operator
Interested in how these algorithms can help your company meet its ambitions, help mitigate operational risks on compliance, improve OPEX performance or beat the war on talent? Get in touch:
Want to learn more  about digital solutions for the water sector? - Contact our Water Technology experts

Want to learn more about digital solutions for the water sector?

Contact our Water Technology experts